Answering this needs the axis. A supplier that is best on paperwork and a supplier that is best on price are both correct answers to different questions.
Compare documentation on a fixed checklist rather than by impression: lot specificity, method section, chromatogram availability, quantified content, water and counter-ion figures, and whether the code is on the vial.
In practice, publish the method with the result. A comparison without the laboratory named and the submission dates given is not reproducible by anyone.
The caveat is that a comparison is a snapshot of the lots compared, and lots change.
Use a fixed documentation checklist rather than an impression.