Answer first: vet the documentation before you vet the supplier, because documentation is the only thing you can assess before spending anything.
Ask what happens if a result comes back outside specification. The answer is informative regardless of what it is, and the question itself tells you something about how it lands.
Repeat the exercise on a second lot months later. Lot-to-lot agreement is the property that actually predicts your next order, and it cannot be established from one submission.
Aggregate community ratings, including the one on this site, are opinion averages rather than measurements and should carry less weight than a single result on your own lot.
A supplier link on this site is marked nofollow and sponsored and is not a recommendation; it is there so a claim can be checked against its source.
Two lots agreeing is worth more than one lot excelling.
edited 20 Oct 2025 by ilaria_bertone — added the placebo-arm figures